Skip to content
YOUR NEXT HOME-COOKED FAVORITE

American Double-Crust Apple Pie

A double-crust sweet pie made from the pastry through to the apple filling.

American~2 hr

8 servings · 5 steps

American Double-Crust Apple Pie

Keep raw and cooked food handling separate; use heat-resistant gloves to hold baking pans and pot handles.

  1. 01

    Make the pastry

    Work the shortening and cold butter into the flour and salt. Gradually add the main portion of ice water, then add small amounts of the reserved ice water according to how the dough comes together. Add only enough for the dough to hold together when squeezed; you do not need to use all the reserved water. Divide into two discs and refrigerate for 30 minutes. Check: the dough holds together and still contains pieces of butter.

    Look for

    The dough holds together and still contains pieces of butter.

    Make the pastry: The dough holds together and still contains pieces of butter.
  2. 02

    Mix the apple filling

    Toss the apples with the lemon juice. Mix the dry filling ingredients together, then add them to the apples. Stir in the optional concentrated juice and vanilla. Heat/temperature: no heating. Check: the apples are evenly coated with the dry mixture.

    Look for

    The apple slices are evenly coated with the dry mixture.

    Mix the apple filling: The apple slices are evenly coated with the dry mixture.
  3. 03

    Assemble and refrigerate the pie

    Roll out each of the two pieces of pastry to about 30 cm. Line a 23 cm pie dish with one piece, add the filling and diced butter, then cover with the other piece, seal the edges and cut steam vents. Refrigerate. Heat/temperature: no heating. Time: 10 minutes.

    Look for

    The edges of the top and bottom crusts are tightly sealed, with steam vents in the top.

    Assemble and refrigerate the pie: The edges of the top and bottom crusts are tightly sealed, with steam vents in the top.
  4. 04

    Bake in two temperature stages

    You may brush with milk and sprinkle with sugar. Place on a baking sheet and bake at the initial temperature, then reduce the temperature. Cover the edges with foil if they become too dark. Heat/temperature: 425°F followed by 375°F (about 218°C followed by 191°C). Time: 20 minutes followed by about 40 minutes. Check: the filling visibly bubbles through the vents.

    Look for

    The filling visibly bubbles through the steam vents, and the edges are not over-browned.

    Bake in two temperature stages: The filling visibly bubbles through the steam vents, and the edges are not over-browned.
  5. 05

    Cool and slice

    Allow to cool completely before slicing. Heat/temperature: no heating. Time: not specified. Check: the filling has set.

    Look for

    The filling has set, and the slices do not release a large amount of juice.

    Cool and slice: The filling has set, and the slices do not release a large amount of juice.

Keep exploring