Skip to content
YOUR NEXT HOME-COOKED FAVORITE

American Turkey Meatloaf

Two free-form turkey meatloaves coated with a sweet-and-sour tomato glaze, divided into 6 servings. Let the softened onion cool before mixing it with the meat.

American~1 hr 30 min

6 servings · 7 steps

American Turkey Meatloaf

Use refrigerated ground turkey that is about 93% lean. Do not wash raw poultry or taste raw meat or egg mixtures. Use separate knives and boards for raw and cooked food, and keep the meat refrigerated while the onion cools. Use a probe to confirm that several points in the thickest center of each loaf reach 74°C. Meat color, red glaze, and timing cannot substitute for temperature measurements. This version uses Worcestershire sauce containing anchovies; check the label for fish and other allergens. Divide cooked food to be stored into small, shallow portions and promptly refrigerate at 4°C or below. Total time at room temperature must not exceed 2 hours; when the ambient temperature exceeds 32°C, it must not exceed 1 hour.

  1. 01

    Preheat and mix the glaze

    Set an oven rack in the middle and preheat to 175°C (350°F in the original recipe). Line a rimmed baking tray with ovenproof heavy-duty foil and brush lightly with oil. Peel and mince the onion and garlic. Mix the ketchup, brown sugar, apple cider vinegar, and ½ teaspoon of mustard for the glaze. Measure out ¼ cup for the meat mixture and keep the rest separate for coating the tops, preventing contamination by raw meat.

    Look for

    The glaze is evenly mixed, the ¼ cup is separate from the remainder, and the tray has a rim to contain juices.

    Preheat and mix the glaze: The glaze is evenly mixed, the ¼ cup is separate from the remainder, and the tray has a rim to contain juices.
  2. 02

    Soften the onion and garlic

    Heat 1 tablespoon of oil in a small pan over medium heat. Add the onion and stir, timing 5 minutes initially before checking. Once the onion is soft but not browned, add the garlic and cook for 1–2 minutes until fragrant. Immediately turn off the heat and move the pan off the burner. Reduce the heat if coloring is too fast.

    Look for

    The onion is soft and translucent, and the garlic is fragrant, with no browned edges.

    Soften the onion and garlic: The onion is soft and translucent, and the garlic is fragrant, with no browned edges.
  3. 03

    Spread out to cool

    Transfer the cooked onion and garlic to a shallow heatproof dish and spread them out. Leave for 5 minutes initially, then check. They must not be hot to the touch before mixing with the meat. If still hot, briefly put the shallow dish in the refrigerator to continue cooling. Keep the turkey and eggs refrigerated throughout, rather than waiting on the counter for a long time.

    Look for

    The onion mixture is not hot, and the meat and eggs are still refrigerated.

    Spread out to cool: The onion mixture is not hot, and the meat and eggs are still refrigerated.
  4. 04

    Combine the seasonings and gently mix the meat

    Beat the eggs in a large bowl and mix in the salt, pepper, sweet paprika, thyme, Worcestershire sauce, the 1½ tablespoons of mustard for the meat, and the reserved ¼ cup of mixed glaze. Add the cooled onion, then the turkey and breadcrumbs. Mix gently and stop once everything is evenly distributed. Do not wash or taste the meat, and wash your hands after touching raw meat or eggs.

    Look for

    No separate egg liquid or dry breadcrumb clumps are visible, and the mixture is evenly moist.

    Combine the seasonings and gently mix the meat: No separate egg liquid or dry breadcrumb clumps are visible, and the mixture is evenly moist.
  5. 05

    Shape two loaves and glaze the tops

    Divide the mixture into two equal portions on the tray. Shape each into a low loaf about 15 centimeters long, 10 centimeters wide, and no more than 4 centimeters high, leaving space between them. Divide all the remaining mixed glaze over the tops and put them straight into the oven. Wash bowls and utensils that touched raw meat.

    Look for

    The two loaves have similar heights of no more than 4 centimeters, with evenly glazed tops.

    Shape two loaves and glaze the tops: The two loaves have similar heights of no more than 4 centimeters, with evenly glazed tops.
  6. 06

    Bake and measure several center points

    Place on the middle rack of the fully preheated 175°C oven and bake for 45 minutes initially. Insert a clean probe from the side into the thickest center of each loaf, avoiding the tray, and recheck at several points. Remove from the oven only when every reading is at least 74°C (165°F). If too low, keep baking and recheck every 5 minutes, cleaning the probe. If the tops become too dark, cover loosely with foil while continuing to cook the centers.

    Look for

    Several points in the thickest center of each loaf are at least 74°C; surface color alone is not enough.

    Bake and measure several center points: Several points in the thickest center of each loaf are at least 74°C; surface color alone is not enough.
  7. 07

    Rest and slice after reaching temperature

    First confirm that each loaf has reached 74°C, then turn off the oven and use oven mitts to take them out. Rest on a heatproof surface for 5 minutes, then use a clean knife to cut each into 3 portions; parsley is optional. Immediately divide any meatloaf being saved into small, shallow portions to cool and refrigerate. Resting cannot replace reaching the required temperature beforehand.

    Look for

    The slices in all six portions hold their shape, the temperature checks have passed, and the hot oven is off.

    Rest and slice after reaching temperature: The slices in all six portions hold their shape, the temperature checks have passed, and the hot oven is off.

Keep exploring